FP Markets
Best Indicators and Simple Strategies for Beginners

How to Choose the Best Forex Broker for Scalping in 2023

Mark Fodor
Written by
Mark Fodor
Jul 2023

With its high-speed and high-volume of trades, scalping is a sought-after strategy in the forex market. However, selecting the best broker for scalping is key as not all brokers cater to the unique requirements of scalping strategies. This article explores how to find the best scalping forex broker, focusing on trading account types, raw spread, forex pairs, and the allowance for trading CFDs. Additionally, we'll review ECN brokers, trading costs, and necessary trading tools.

Ensuring Forex Broker's Compliance and Security in 2023

When it comes to forex trading, safety should always be a top priority. Ensuring your chosen broker is regulated by reputable financial authorities is a critical first step. Regulatory bodies like the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the UK, the Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC), or the Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) provide strict oversight, enforcing regulations that protect traders from potential broker misconduct.

These regulatory bodies make sure that brokers maintain a transparent operating environment, adhere to fair trading practices, and provide adequate financial protection for their clients. They require brokers to segregate clients' funds from their operational funds, meaning your money is stored separately and can't be used by the broker for its business activities.

Broker Regulation

Understanding the Scalping Policy of Your Forex Broker

Scalping is a unique trading strategy that involves opening and closing numerous trades within a short timeframe to capitalize on small price changes. While it's a legal and valid strategy, it's not universally accepted by all brokers.

The primary reason for this is that scalping can place a considerable burden on a broker's systems due to the high volume of trades. In addition, some brokers operating on a dealing desk model, where the broker sets the bid and ask prices and often takes the other side of a client's trade, may view scalping unfavorably as it can reduce their opportunity to profit.

Therefore, it's imperative to confirm the broker's scalping policy before signing up. Brokers that allow scalping usually mention it clearly in their terms and conditions or trading policy documents. They may categorize their scalping policy under high-frequency trading or automated trading rules, as some scalpers use algorithms or bots to carry out rapid trades.

Some brokers not only tolerate scalping but also optimize their services for scalpers. These brokers typically provide features such as low spreads, fast execution speeds, and sophisticated trading platforms, all vital components for successful scalping.

Be cautious about brokers who claim to allow scalping but have vague or complicated terms that may permit them to intervene in or manipulate your trades. A reliable broker will have clear, transparent policies, allowing you to trade without unwarranted interruptions or interference.

Evaluating Speed and Stability of Forex Trading Platforms for Scalping

Scalping is a trading strategy that relies heavily on speed and efficiency. Given that scalpers aim to profit from minor price fluctuations over very short timeframes, the trading platform's speed and stability become paramount.

A slow or unreliable platform can cause significant issues such as delays in trade execution, missed trading opportunities, or even unexpected losses. Hence, it's crucial to choose a broker that provides a robust and high-speed trading platform capable of handling the high-frequency trading that scalping entails.

Look for platforms that offer features like one-click trading, which allows you to execute trades quickly with a single click, eliminating the need for confirmation screens that can cause delays. This feature is particularly beneficial for scalpers, given the fast-paced nature of their trading style.
Furthermore, stability is another crucial aspect to consider. The platform should run smoothly without crashes or errors, even during periods of high market volatility when the demand on the system is greatest. Nothing can be more frustrating for a scalper than a platform that freezes or crashes in the middle of trading.

In addition to speed and stability, consider the platform's interface. It should be user-friendly and intuitive, allowing you to navigate and execute trades swiftly. Any complexity or cumbersome process could cost precious seconds, which can be critical in scalping.

Also, consider the platform's analytical capabilities. Even though scalping is typically more execution-focused, having access to real-time charts, technical indicators, and other analytical tools can help make more informed trading decisions.

Choosing a Scalping Forex Broker with Low Spreads and Commissions

Given the nature of scalping, where profits are often made from small price movements, transaction costs can significantly impact your trading results. Thus, a broker's spread and commission structure is a crucial factor to consider.

Spreads, the difference between the bid and ask price, are essentially the cost you pay to enter a trade. Since scalpers execute a high volume of trades, even slightly wider spreads can add up over time, eating into your profits. Therefore, you need a broker that consistently offers tight spreads.

Keep in mind that spreads can vary by account type. Some brokers offer lower spreads on their premium or VIP accounts, which might require a higher minimum deposit. Make sure to weigh the benefits of tighter spreads against the increased initial investment.

Commissions are another form of transaction cost, which some brokers charge on trades in addition to or instead of spreads. Like spreads, commissions can add up quickly when you're trading frequently. Be aware that some brokers might advertise "zero spread" accounts but charge high commissions, which can end up being more costly.

Importance of Order Execution Speed in Forex Scalping

Order execution refers to how quickly a broker can carry out your trade orders at your requested price. Slow order execution could lead to a phenomenon called 'slippage,' where orders are filled at a worse price than expected. In a market as volatile as forex, prices can change within milliseconds, and delayed order execution can result in slippage, negatively impacting your trading outcomes.

Therefore, it's essential to select a broker known for its fast and reliable order execution. Some brokers offer what's known as market execution, which guarantees your orders will be filled, albeit not necessarily at the price you've requested. On the other hand, instant execution guarantees your price but not the execution of the order, especially in periods of high volatility.

It's also crucial to investigate whether the broker has a 'no re-quote' policy. Re-quotes occur when the price of a currency pair changes as you're making a trade, and the broker asks if you wish to proceed at the new price. For a scalper, this could mean missing the opportunity entirely or entering the market at an unfavorable time.

Check user reviews and broker specifications to get a sense of their order execution quality. Some brokers even provide statistics on their execution speed and rate of slippage. A broker with a proven track record of high-quality, fast order execution can significantly enhance your scalping strategy's success.

Navigating Stop-Level Rules with the Best Scalping Brokers

Brokers set stop-levels based on their risk tolerance and business model. Dealing Desk brokers, who take the opposite side of your trades, may impose higher stop levels as frequent close stops can reduce their profitability. On the other hand, Non-Dealing Desk brokers or ECN (Electronic Communication Network) brokers usually have lower or even zero stop-levels as they pass your orders directly to the interbank market.

Choosing a broker with a low or zero stop-level provides you with more flexibility and control over your trades. It allows you to set tight stop-loss and take-profit levels, a crucial aspect of risk management in scalping.

Some brokers may have rules about how long you must hold a position open (the 'holding period') before it can qualify as a legitimate trade rather than a scalping trade. Others may have rules on the minimum pip difference required between the market price and your Stop Loss or Take Profit orders.


What does scalping refer to in the forex market and how does it work?
Scalping refers to a popular trading strategy where forex traders perform a high volume of short-term trades within a trading day to capitalize on small market movements. Scalping requires speedy decision making and excellent understanding of the forex market.

Do all forex brokers allow scalping on their platforms?
Not all brokers allow scalping. It's important to read broker reviews and understand their trading conditions before choosing a forex broker for scalping. 

What should I consider when looking for the best forex broker for scalping in 2023?
When choosing a forex broker for scalping, consider the trading conditions, whether the broker is regulated, if they offer MT4 and MT5 trading platforms or other tools for automated trading strategies, and if they provide ECN or STP trading accounts. 

How can I ensure that the broker I choose for scalping is reputable and trustworthy?
To ensure you're dealing with a reputable broker, check if they are regulated by a recognized financial authority, read online broker reviews, and ensure they offer transparency in their trading costs. 

Is scalping allowed with forex and CFD brokers?
While some forex and CFD brokers allow scalping, others may have restrictions. It's always best to check a broker's policy on scalping before opening a trading account.

How can I identify the best forex brokers for scalping in 2023?
To identify the best forex brokers for scalping, consider factors like trading costs, speed of order execution, platform stability, and whether scalping is allowed. Also, look for broker reviews recommending specific brokers for scalping.

How do I choose the right broker to suit my scalping strategy?
When selecting a broker for scalping, consider your specific trading needs, such as access to different forex pairs, trading tools for scalping, and the broker's policy on automated strategies. Reviewing brokers that specialize in scalping can also be useful.